{"data":[{"_meta":{"removal_type":"deleted","retrieved_2nd_on":1782608008,"was_deleted_later":true},"all_awardings":[],"allow_live_comments":false,"approved_at_utc":null,"approved_by":null,"archived":false,"author":"Waste_Project_7864","author_flair_background_color":null,"author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_richtext":[],"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"author_flair_text_color":null,"author_flair_type":"text","author_fullname":"t2_fwicflkk","author_is_blocked":false,"author_patreon_flair":false,"author_premium":false,"awarders":[],"banned_at_utc":null,"banned_by":null,"can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"category":null,"clicked":false,"content_categories":null,"contest_mode":false,"created":1782478382,"created_utc":1782478382,"discussion_type":null,"distinguished":null,"domain":"i.redd.it","downs":0,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"gildings":{},"hidden":false,"hide_score":false,"id":"1ug60fz","is_created_from_ads_ui":false,"is_crosspostable":true,"is_meta":false,"is_original_content":false,"is_reddit_media_domain":true,"is_robot_indexable":true,"is_self":false,"is_video":false,"likes":null,"link_flair_background_color":"#e0b57f","link_flair_css_class":"","link_flair_richtext":[{"e":"text","t":"📜 Knowledge Drop"}],"link_flair_template_id":"2cf92b30-3f84-11f0-8675-8ef88468942b","link_flair_text":"📜 Knowledge Drop","link_flair_text_color":"dark","link_flair_type":"richtext","location_lat":null,"location_long":null,"location_name":null,"locked":false,"media":null,"media_embed":{},"media_only":false,"mod_note":null,"mod_reason_by":null,"mod_reason_title":null,"mod_reports":[],"name":"t3_1ug60fz","no_follow":true,"num_comments":4,"num_crossposts":0,"num_reports":null,"outbound_link":{"created":null,"expiration":null,"url":"https://i.redd.it/84koa349jm9h1.jpeg"},"over_18":false,"permalink":"/r/vedicastrologyexperts/comments/1ug60fz/when_you_should_not_wear_a_gemstone_according_to/","pinned":false,"post_hint":"image","preview":{"enabled":true,"images":[{"id":"84koa349jm9h1","resolutions":[{"height":108,"url":"https://preview.redd.it/84koa349jm9h1.jpeg?width=108&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=9dd1da23d9974418e54fff4324b91902e9dfc600","width":108},{"height":216,"url":"https://preview.redd.it/84koa349jm9h1.jpeg?width=216&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=2773de68f9116623b20acb88ebd16300fdbe7ac8","width":216},{"height":320,"url":"https://preview.redd.it/84koa349jm9h1.jpeg?width=320&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=e2387bc9b6177257cedf43758b82bbd1caf99057","width":320},{"height":640,"url":"https://preview.redd.it/84koa349jm9h1.jpeg?width=640&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=c30348da05fc95dd74adda0fd4b61e28162cf8bf","width":640},{"height":960,"url":"https://preview.redd.it/84koa349jm9h1.jpeg?width=960&crop=smart&auto=webp&s=87a14aaeeaeaa6f0febe4bd258e05a68ca5dc46f","width":960}],"source":{"height":1024,"url":"https://preview.redd.it/84koa349jm9h1.jpeg?auto=webp&s=36cfb21bc7bdbfc322931fadd315f3e05e131d37","width":1024},"variants":{}}]},"pwls":6,"quarantine":false,"removal_reason":null,"removed_by":null,"removed_by_category":null,"report_reasons":null,"retrieved_on":1782478400,"saved":false,"score":0,"secure_media":null,"secure_media_embed":{},"selftext":"One of the most common things I come across during readings is people wearing gemstones because a family pandit, someone their parents have trusted for decades, advised them to do so. By the time they reach me, the stone has often been on their finger for months, sometimes even years.\n\nOut of curiosity, I usually ask a simple question.\n\n*\"Has it made any noticeable difference?\"*\n\nMore often than not, I am met with silence. Sometimes they pause to think. Sometimes they smile awkwardly. Most simply admit they never really noticed any change.\n\nWhen I examine their horoscope, I find that in almost ninety percent of these cases, the gemstone is either unsuitable for the chart or the planet itself is incapable of delivering the results people expect from it.\n\nThat is what inspired this post.\n\nToday, I want to discuss some of the situations where I would never recommend wearing a gemstone. In a separate post, I will talk about the circumstances where gemstones can be remarkably effective.\n\nUnlike mantras or simple pooja remedies, which are generally safe, free of cost, and require only your time and consistency, I approach gemstones with far greater caution. Not merely because they are expensive, but because they are among the most potent remedies available in Jyotish.\n\nA gemstone does not create a new destiny. It strengthens the energy of a planet exactly as it exists in your horoscope, amplifying both its strengths and its weaknesses.\n\nThis is also why I rarely recommend bracelets made from stones like Lapis Lazuli, Amethyst, Jade, and similar crystals that are marketed as universal remedies for confidence, healing, protection, or attracting abundance. In my experience, these have become a popular product among people selling crystals, tarot readings, and other spiritual services because they can be marketed to almost everyone regardless of their horoscope.\n\nPersonally, I have not observed them producing consistent astrological results beyond what could simply be explained by a placebo effect. If I recommend a gemstone, I should be able to explain exactly which planet I am strengthening, why I am strengthening it, and what results I expect from doing so.\n\nFor example, consider a Taurus ascendant with Venus placed in the second house. Wearing a diamond may certainly strengthen finances. But Venus also rules the sixth house. Strengthening it may simultaneously activate health issues or disputes within the family. No amount of financial gain is worth creating a bigger problem elsewhere in the chart.\n\nI often compare wearing a gemstone to undertaking a tantric sadhana. The practice itself is neither good nor bad. In the hands of someone who truly understands it, it can become a source of extraordinary transformation. But approached carelessly, with incomplete knowledge or the wrong intention, the very same practice can create unnecessary suffering. Gemstones work in much the same way. They do not choose what to strengthen. Your horoscope does.\n\nHere are a few situations where I generally avoid recommending them.\n\n**1. The planet rules or occupies the 6th, 8th, or 12th house**\n\nThis is one of the very first things I examine.\n\nIf strengthening a planet also means strengthening houses associated with hardships, why would I recommend doing so without careful consideration?\n\nCertainly, such a planet can appear to produce desirable outcomes. It may help someone win a legal battle through the 6th house, receive an inheritance through the 8th, or settle abroad through the 12th. The same planet may also increase illness, conflict, instability in relationships or career, sudden reversals, unnecessary expenditure, losses, or periods of isolation, depending upon the overall promise of the horoscope.\n\nEven if that planet is exalted or forms a Raja Yoga elsewhere, I doubt whether the benefits truly outweigh the risks.\n\n**2. The planet is debilitated in either the D1 or the D9 chart**\n\nOne of the most common misconceptions is that Neechbhanga or Parivartan completely erases debilitation. That is not how I interpret these yogas.\n\nThey undoubtedly change how the planet expresses itself and may even produce excellent results under favourable circumstances. But they do not erase the planet's underlying weakness.\n\nSince a gemstone amplifies the very essence of a planet, I generally avoid strengthening one that lacks a stable foundation in either the natal chart or the Navamsa.\n\nOne additional chart I personally pay close attention to is the D60. Although often overlooked, it remains one of the most profound divisional charts because it reflects karmic patterns carried into this lifetime. A planet that appears promising elsewhere may tell a very different story when examined there.\n\n**3. The planet is a functional malefic**\n\nThis is perhaps the simplest principle.\n\nIf a planet functions as a malefic for your ascendant, amplifying its energy may also amplify the difficulties it governs.\n\nUnless there is an exceptionally compelling reason supported by the chart as a whole, I generally avoid prescribing gemstones for such planets. In my practice, such exceptions account for less than ten percent of the cases I see.\n\n**4. The planet is combust or retrograde**\n\nThis is a tricky one because a combust or retrograde planet's gemstone needs to be chosen with great care. These conditions do not automatically disqualify a gemstone.\n\nBefore concluding, I study its house ownership, the house it occupies, the nakshatra it resides in, its dignity across divisional charts, and the broader role it plays within the horoscope.\n\nThere are situations where I may recommend a softer substitute rather than the primary gemstone, but decisions like these cannot be made by following a checklist. They demand careful judgement and a holistic understanding of the chart.\n\n**5. The planet simply does not have enough strength to produce meaningful results**\n\nIn such cases, strengthening the planet through a gemstone often produces little to no noticeable change because there simply is not enough planetary strength to amplify in the first place.\n\nBefore recommending any gemstone, I first ask a simple question: *Does this planet even have the capacity to deliver the results we are expecting from it?* If the answer is no, there is very little point in prescribing a gemstone.\n\n\n\nThese are only some of the factors I consider before recommending a gemstone. Once you wear one, you are strengthening that planetary energy every single day for as long as you continue wearing it. That is not a decision I believe should ever be made casually.\n\nI hope this gave you a different perspective on gemstones.\n\nIf you enjoyed reading this post, you may also like my last article, [Learning Vedic Astrology: Common Mistakes Beginners Make While Reading Birth Charts](https://www.reddit.com/r/vedicastrologyexperts/comments/1udg3qn/learning_vedic_astrology_common_mistakes/)**.**\n\nHave a great weekend!","send_replies":true,"spoiler":false,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"vedicastrologyexperts","subreddit_id":"t5_el8uxi","subreddit_name_prefixed":"r/vedicastrologyexperts","subreddit_subscribers":12994,"subreddit_type":"public","suggested_sort":null,"thumbnail":"https://preview.redd.it/84koa349jm9h1.jpeg?width=140&height=140&auto=webp&s=100b56abec43db60f32ba3e7e48116f694c862ec","thumbnail_height":140,"thumbnail_width":140,"title":"When You Should NOT Wear a Gemstone According to Vedic Astrology","top_awarded_type":null,"total_awards_received":0,"treatment_tags":[],"ups":0,"upvote_ratio":0.25,"url":"https://i.redd.it/84koa349jm9h1.jpeg","url_overridden_by_dest":"https://i.redd.it/84koa349jm9h1.jpeg","user_reports":[],"view_count":null,"visited":false,"websocket_url":"wss://k8s-lb.wss.redditmedia.com/link/1ug60fz?m=AQAAB8JBaugntBEaxDdkDodbmbMSulj_FD64XdDjPjC0Nm90TR-l","wls":6}]}