{"data":[{"archived":false,"author":"[deleted]","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"body":"Strong umbrellas exist, perhaps not at a price point you are willing to pay.\n\nRemoved","can_gild":false,"can_mod_post":false,"controversiality":0,"created_utc":1524773112,"distinguished":"moderator","edited":false,"gilded":0,"id":"dy0qvbc","is_submitter":false,"link_id":"t3_8f4kyc","no_follow":true,"parent_id":"t3_8f4kyc","permalink":"/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/8f4kyc/eli5_how_come_umbrellas_are_so_suseptible_to_wind/dy0qvbc/","removal_reason":null,"retrieved_on":1526777211,"score":1,"score_hidden":true,"send_replies":true,"stickied":true,"subreddit":"explainlikeimfive","subreddit_id":"t5_2sokd","subreddit_type":"public","name":"t1_dy0qvbc","ups":1},{"archived":false,"author":"jpj007","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"body":"If you can come up with an umbrella replacement that is just as effective for deflecting rain without the downside of being blown by wind, then enjoy being a multimillionaire.","can_gild":true,"can_mod_post":false,"controversiality":0,"created_utc":1524765430,"distinguished":null,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"id":"dy0i53q","is_submitter":false,"link_id":"t3_8f4kyc","no_follow":true,"parent_id":"t3_8f4kyc","permalink":"/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/8f4kyc/eli5_how_come_umbrellas_are_so_suseptible_to_wind/dy0i53q/","removal_reason":null,"retrieved_on":1526772664,"score":2,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"explainlikeimfive","subreddit_id":"t5_2sokd","subreddit_type":"public","name":"t1_dy0i53q","ups":2},{"archived":false,"author":"LincolnImp68","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"body":"as to why they're designed like that, i'm guessing it's down to the best of a bad lot, if you changed shape you'd lose protection from rain from an angle or it'd be too bulky or heavy to carry or use. Any bowed shape is going to suffer from the above problem of lift.","can_gild":true,"can_mod_post":false,"controversiality":0,"created_utc":1524765124,"distinguished":null,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"id":"dy0hsa0","is_submitter":false,"link_id":"t3_8f4kyc","no_follow":true,"parent_id":"t1_dy0hgl0","permalink":"/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/8f4kyc/eli5_how_come_umbrellas_are_so_suseptible_to_wind/dy0hsa0/","removal_reason":null,"retrieved_on":1526772477,"score":1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"explainlikeimfive","subreddit_id":"t5_2sokd","subreddit_type":"public","name":"t1_dy0hsa0","ups":1},{"archived":false,"author":"BlindPelican","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"body":"Seems like umbrellas, like many other tools, have specific applications so some are made for convenience and being able to be easily packed, and others are more sturdy but bulkier.\n\nI was surprised at the variety of umbrellas available - https://www.rewardme.in/family/activities/article/practical-umbrellas-for-the-rainy-season\n\nIt's probably worth noting that while the overall design might be susceptible to wind, a better design hasn't been created yet so there's your million dollar idea.","can_gild":true,"can_mod_post":false,"controversiality":0,"created_utc":1524765009,"distinguished":null,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"id":"dy0hnix","is_submitter":false,"link_id":"t3_8f4kyc","no_follow":true,"parent_id":"t3_8f4kyc","permalink":"/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/8f4kyc/eli5_how_come_umbrellas_are_so_suseptible_to_wind/dy0hnix/","removal_reason":null,"retrieved_on":1526772408,"score":1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"explainlikeimfive","subreddit_id":"t5_2sokd","subreddit_type":"public","name":"t1_dy0hnix","ups":1},{"archived":false,"author":"LincolnImp68","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"body":"It's the exact same thing that helps aircraft fly. The Bernoulli Principle is what occurs, air flow past the umbrella has to go faster over than around thus creating low pressure above the umbrella providing lift, just like the wing of an aircraft","can_gild":true,"can_mod_post":false,"controversiality":0,"created_utc":1524764840,"distinguished":null,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"id":"dy0hgl0","is_submitter":false,"link_id":"t3_8f4kyc","no_follow":true,"parent_id":"t3_8f4kyc","permalink":"/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/8f4kyc/eli5_how_come_umbrellas_are_so_suseptible_to_wind/dy0hgl0/","removal_reason":null,"retrieved_on":1526772308,"score":0,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"explainlikeimfive","subreddit_id":"t5_2sokd","subreddit_type":"public","name":"t1_dy0hgl0","ups":0},{"archived":false,"author":"nikoshgrikos","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"body":"There are umbrellas with flaps on top.\n\n Air will go through, lifting the flap when there is a strong gust of wind. ","can_gild":true,"can_mod_post":false,"controversiality":0,"created_utc":1524764840,"distinguished":null,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"id":"dy0hgkm","is_submitter":false,"link_id":"t3_8f4kyc","no_follow":true,"parent_id":"t3_8f4kyc","permalink":"/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/8f4kyc/eli5_how_come_umbrellas_are_so_suseptible_to_wind/dy0hgkm/","removal_reason":null,"retrieved_on":1526772308,"score":1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"explainlikeimfive","subreddit_id":"t5_2sokd","subreddit_type":"public","name":"t1_dy0hgkm","ups":1},{"archived":false,"author":"Virdice","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"body":"I'm not an umbrella engineer\nBut a thing that wont work 80% of the time that it should,us rather pointless","can_gild":true,"can_mod_post":false,"controversiality":0,"created_utc":1524764704,"distinguished":null,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"id":"dy0hb07","is_submitter":true,"link_id":"t3_8f4kyc","no_follow":true,"parent_id":"t1_dy0h6r5","permalink":"/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/8f4kyc/eli5_how_come_umbrellas_are_so_suseptible_to_wind/dy0hb07/","removal_reason":null,"retrieved_on":1526772228,"score":1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"explainlikeimfive","subreddit_id":"t5_2sokd","subreddit_type":"public","name":"t1_dy0hb07","ups":1},{"archived":false,"author":"Pegajace","author_flair_css_class":null,"author_flair_template_id":null,"author_flair_text":null,"body":"Being susceptible to wind is an inevitable consequence of being light and having a large surface area. How would you propose making an umbrella wind-resistant?","can_gild":true,"can_mod_post":false,"controversiality":0,"created_utc":1524764597,"distinguished":null,"edited":false,"gilded":0,"id":"dy0h6r5","is_submitter":false,"link_id":"t3_8f4kyc","no_follow":true,"parent_id":"t3_8f4kyc","permalink":"/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/8f4kyc/eli5_how_come_umbrellas_are_so_suseptible_to_wind/dy0h6r5/","removal_reason":null,"retrieved_on":1526772167,"score":1,"score_hidden":false,"send_replies":true,"stickied":false,"subreddit":"explainlikeimfive","subreddit_id":"t5_2sokd","subreddit_type":"public","name":"t1_dy0h6r5","ups":1}]}